In theory, the arrival of e-bikes and e-scooters ought to be an exceptionally welcome development. By offering people fun, emission-free light transportation, they present the opportunity to diversify the transportation mix away from cars and trucks, easing street congestion and offering some liberating options for freedom of movement to those who for reasons of youth, finances, or other causes, may not be able to drive on their own or benefit from public transportation. A $370 Walmart e-bike with a 31-mile range could put affordable urban transportation on the menu in a way that even the most affordable sub-compact car cannot.
■ In practice, the technology’s rapid adoption rate has outpaced the evolution of the legal environment and the social norms required to make the rapid adoption go well -- or safely. And there’s a nasty hazard that the problem is going to come into distinct relief as sunlight hours shorten.
■ The problem is that these ultra-light vehicles share features of both automobiles and human-powered bicycles or scooters, but they don’t share all of the features of either. Unfortunately, some enthusiastic adopters are quick to assume all of the advantages of having a metaphorical foot in both worlds without accepting the risks and responsibilities of the same.
■ To other pedestrians, this means greater risks on bike paths and sidewalks. Under all-human power, an uphill climb is bound to mean slower going. One of the leading selling points of an electrically-enhanced bike or scooter is that an uphill climb doesn’t have to mean extra work or slower motion -- creating a situation with greater speed disparities between people traveling both in the same direction and in opposite ones. And speed dsparities are what lead to serious injuries.
■ But perhaps even more dangerously, people traveling at street-vehicle speeds but using sidewalks and bike paths still often cross intersecting roadways. Instead of following pedestrian-style rules and stopping to look both ways before crossing, many blast through intersections (and stop signs or crosswalk signals) at full speed -- assuming all of the rights of a pedestrian, but none of the responsibilities of a vehicle in traffic. People are getting hurt and killed this way.
■ All of this is exacerbated by the number of children and adolescents doing the “driving” -- and shrinking daylight hours make the possibilities for collision all the more frequent. As the market appetite grows for these vehicles, both laws and cultural norms around rider responsibility need to speed up.


